The Fifth Avenue Hotel: prices, traveler reviews & what it’s worth
Tucked in NoMad on Fifth Avenue, The Fifth Avenue Hotel occupies a reimagined Gilded Age landmark where carved stone details meet eclectic, art-filled interiors. Guests drift between candlelit salons, Chef Andrew Carmellini’s Café and the portrait-lined bar, enjoying attentive, imaginative service and a quietly theatrical sense of charm.
SecretNests keeps first-party traveler reviews and value opinions separate from provider facts and external review signals.
What travelers think it's worth
Not enough first-party stay data yet. Add your stay to help establish the fair-value range.
Tell travelers what the stay was actually like.
Share the experience in your own words. If you remember what you paid or what you’d happily pay again, add that too.
Add your stay →About 2 minutes · not a star rating
Is The Fifth Avenue Hotel worth it?
SecretNests does not yet have enough first-party stays to publish a traveler fair-value verdict for this hotel. The page shows price context, hotel facts and external traveler evidence separately while the first-party sample builds.
SecretNests keeps first-party traveler value, observed/estimated prices and external review evidence as separate signals.
The Fifth Avenue Hotel at a glance
| Location | New York, United States |
|---|---|
| Brand | Not Available |
| Category | luxury |
| Estimated nightly range | $900–$1,500 |
| Latest observed rate | $1,535 |
| Traveler median would-pay | Sample building |
| External review signal | — |
How much does The Fifth Avenue Hotel cost?
The latest observed bookable rate on SecretNests is $1,535 per night. The broader estimated price band is $900–$1,500.
Estimated historical range: $900–$1,500 per night.
2026-12-25 → 2026-12-27 · NOMAD, TOWER, QUEEN BED · before taxes/fees
Amenities
External traveler evidence
- Nuitee's aggregated guest-review sentiment averages 9.4/10. Stronger areas: Location 10.0/10, Overall Experience 9.9/10. Weaker areas: Cleanliness 8.5/10, Value for Money 8.9/10. source
Nearby / comparable alternatives
New York, United States · $900–$1,500Waldorf Astoria New York
New York, United States · $900–$1,500The Ritz-Carlton New York, Central Park
New York, United States · $900–$1,500Pendry Manhattan West
New York, United States · $900–$1,500
The Fifth Avenue Hotel FAQ
How much does The Fifth Avenue Hotel cost?
The latest observed bookable rate on SecretNests is $1,535 per night. The broader estimated price band is $900–$1,500.
Is The Fifth Avenue Hotel worth it?
SecretNests does not yet have enough first-party stays to publish a traveler fair-value verdict for this hotel. The page shows price context, hotel facts and external traveler evidence separately while the first-party sample builds.
What do guest reviews say about The Fifth Avenue Hotel?
SecretNests has 1 structured traveler-evidence item on this page. They are shown separately from first-party price opinions.
Stayed at The Fifth Avenue Hotel?
Share the stay in your own words. Price and value details are optional, but useful when you have them.
Hotel image via Nuitee Connect